Building Web Services the REST Way
Roger L. Costello
The PO service responds to the HTTP POST with a URL to the submitted PO. Thus,
the client can retrieve the PO any time thereafter (to update/edit it).
The PO has become a piece of information which is shared between the client and
the server. The shared information (PO) is given an address (URL) by the server
and is exposed as a Web service.
I will first provide a brief introduction to REST and then describe how
to build Web services in the REST style.
What is REST?
REST is a term coined by Roy Fielding in his Ph.D. dissertation  to
describe an architecture style of networked systems. REST is
an acronym standing for Representational State Transfer.
Why is it called Representational State Transfer?
The Web is comprised of resources. A resource is any item of interest.
For example, the Boeing Aircraft Corp may define a 747 resource.
Clients may access that resource with this URL:
A representation of the resource is returned
(e.g., Boeing747.html). The representation places the client application in a state. The
result of the client traversing a hyperlink in Boeing747.html is another
resource is accessed. The new representation places the client application
into yet another state. Thus, the client application changes (transfers)
state with each resource representation --> Representational State Transfer!
Here is Roy Fielding's explanation of the meaning of Representational State Transfer:
"Representational State Transfer is intended to evoke an image of how a well-designed
Web application behaves: a network of web pages (a virtual state-machine), where
the user progresses through an application by selecting links (state transitions), resulting
in the next page (representing the next state of the application) being transferred to the
user and rendered for their use."
Motivation for REST
The motivation for REST was to capture the characteristics of the Web which
made the Web successful. Subsequently these characteristics are being used to
guide the evolution of the Web.
REST - An Architectural Style, Not a Standard
REST is not a standard. You will not see the W3C putting out a REST specification.
You will not see IBM or Microsoft or Sun selling a REST developer's toolkit. Why?
Because REST is just an architectural style. You can't bottle up that style. You
can only understand it, and design your Web services in that style. (Analogous to
the client-server architectural style. There is no client-server standard.)
While REST is not a standard, it does use standards:
- XML/HTML/GIF/JPEG/etc (Resource Representations)
- text/xml, text/html, image/gif, image/jpeg, etc (MIME Types)
The Classic REST System
The Web is a REST system! Many of those Web services that you have been
using these many years - book-ordering services, search services,
online dictionary services, etc - are REST-based Web services. Alas,
you have been using REST, building REST services and you didn't even know it.
REST is concerned with the "big picture" of the Web. It does not deal with
implementation details (e.g., using Java servlets or CGI to implement a Web service).
So let's look at an example of creating a Web service from the REST "big picture" perspective.
Parts Depot Web Services
Parts Depot, Inc (fictitious company) has deployed some web services to enable its
Let's consider how each of these services are implemented in a RESTful fashion.
- get a list of parts
- get detailed information about a particular part
- submit a Purchase Order (PO)
Get Parts List
The web service makes available a URL to a parts list resource. For example, a client
would use this URL to get the parts list:
Note that "how" the web service generates the parts list is completely transparent
to the client. All the client knows is that if he/she submits the above URL then
a document containing the list of parts is returned.
Since the implementation is transparent to clients,
Parts Depot is free to modify the underlying implementation of this
resource without impacting clients. This is loose coupling.
Here's the document that the client receives:
[Assume that through content negotiation the service determined that
the client wants the representation as XML (for machine-to-machine processing).]
Note that the parts list has links to get detailed info about each part.
This is a key feature of REST. The client transfers from one state to
the next by examining and choosing from among the alternative URLs
in the response document.
Get Detailed Part Data
The web service makes available a URL to each part resource. Example, here's
how a client requests part 00345:
Here's the document that the client receives:
Again observe how this data is linked to still more data - the specification
for this part may be found by traversing the hyperlink. Each response
document allows the client to drill down to get more detailed information.
The web service makes available a URL to submit a PO. The client creates a PO
instance document which conforms to the PO schema that Parts Depot has designed
(and publicized in a WSDL document). The client submits PO.xml as the payload of
an HTTP POST.
Logical URLs versus Physical URLs
A resource is a conceptual entity. A representation is a concrete manifestation
of the resource. This URL:
is a logical URL, not a physical URL. Thus, there doesn't need to be, for example,
a static HTML page for each part. In fact, if there were a million parts then a
million static HTML pages would not be a very attractive design.
[Implementation detail: Parts Depot could implement the service that gets detailed
data about a particular part by employing a Java Servlet which parses the string
after the host name, uses the part number to query the parts database, formulate
the query results as XML, and then return the XML as the payload of the HTTP response.]
As a matter of style URLs should not reveal the implementation technique used.
You need to be free to change your implementation without impacting clients or having
REST Web Services Characteristics
Here are the characteristics of REST:
- Client-Server: a pull-based interaction style: consuming components pull
- Stateless: each request from client to server must contain all the
information necessary to understand the request, and cannot take advantage
of any stored context on the server.
- Cache: to improve network efficiency responses must be capable of being
labeled as cacheable or non-cacheable.
- Uniform interface: all resources are accessed with a generic interface
(e.g., HTTP GET, POST, PUT, DELETE).
- Named resources - the system is comprised of resources which are named
using a URL.
- Interconnected resource representations - the representations of the
resources are interconnected using URLs, thereby enabling a client to
progress from one state to another.
- Layered components - intermediaries, such as proxy servers, cache servers,
gateways, etc, can be inserted between clients and resources to support
performance, security, etc.
Principles of REST Web Service Design
1. The key to creating Web Services in a REST network (i.e., the Web) is to
identify all of the conceptual entities that you wish to expose as services.
Above we saw some examples of resources: parts list,
detailed part data, purchase order.
2. Create a URL to each resource.
The resources should be nouns, not verbs. For example, do not use this:
Note the verb, getPart. Instead, use a noun:
3. Categorize your resources according to whether clients can just receive a
representation of the resource, or whether clients can modify (add to) the
resource. For the former, make those resources accessible using an HTTP GET.
For the later, make those resources accessible using HTTP POST, PUT, and/or DELETE.
4. All resources accessible via HTTP GET should be side-effect free. That is, the
resource should just return a representation of the resource. Invoking the
resource should not result in modifying the resource.
5. No man/woman is an island. Likewise, no representation should be an island. In other
words, put hyperlinks within resource representations to enable clients to
drill down for more information, and/or to obtain related information.
6. Design to reveal data gradually. Don't reveal everything in a single response document.
Provide hyperlinks to obtain more details.
7. Specify the format of response data using a schema (DTD, W3C Schema, RelaxNG, or Schematron).
For those services that require a POST or PUT to it, also provide a schema to
specify the format of the response.
8. Describe how your services are to be invoked using either a WSDL document, or simply
an HTML document.
This article described REST as an architectural style. In fact, it's
the architectural style of the Web. REST describes what makes the Web
work well. Adhering to the REST principles will make your services
work well in the context of the Web.
In a future article I will write about the evolution of the Web using
the REST principles.
Thanks to Robert Leftwich and Philip Eskelin for their very helpful comments in creating this document.